The Natural Fraud of Things
To Mark, a clearcut gas lighter
From June 14 to Nov 08, 2026
Is this the same family who spread the open secret that if Chris were invited to his own mother's funeral, none of you would go?
Because you're afraid of me?
That's hard to believe. If you were truly afraid of me, you wouldn't have acted the way you have toward me for years.
Is this the same family who agreed that Tony's decision to treat me as persona non grata at his wedding was perfectly acceptable and normal, and in which no one thought to suggest that such a stance might be inappropriate, particularly given that I was living thousands of miles away on the other side of the globe and would almost certainly have had no interest in attending anyway? Especially when it was done to accommodate the man who molested my daughter and to ensure that his comfort would not be inconvenienced?
You once asked Gene, behind my back and without my knowledge, "What happens if Chris loses everything?" Gene's response, again behind my back and without my knowledge, was, "It's okay. He's a survivor."
To answer that question, we must first define the word everything.
This is neither a subjective concept nor a matter for debate. Everything means everything.
If one were to list every person, place, possession, opportunity, ambition, relationship, memory, and possibility that makes up a life, that list would stretch toward infinity.
My home.
My sense of safety.
My health.
My peace of mind.
My reputation.
My income.
My career.
My daily stability.
My friendships.
My family's trust.
My relationship with you.
My dignity.
My confidence.
My plans for the future.
My opportunities.
My sense of belonging.
My memories.
My possessions.
My creative work.
My independence.
My time.
My energy.
My hope.
My self-respect.
Even my ability to begin again.
And still the list would remain woefully incomplete.
The universe may eventually run out of stars before such an inventory runs out of items.
What I have been trying to do is find myself again. To understand my strengths and weaknesses. To discover where my boundaries ought to be and whom they ought to keep out.
I have lived with depression since before junior high school. It has accompanied me for decades.
Since Jennifer and Joshua were taken from my life, I have not laughed once. The smiles people see from me are often manufactured, a professional tool required by my work as a communications instructor.
When Jonathan or Reanne need guidance, do you and your wife reassure each other that they will be fine if they lose everything? Do you discuss whether they can simply become survivors? Do you comfort yourselves with the idea that loss builds character when the loss belongs to someone else?
This is my life now.
I hesitate to tell you what is going well or what is going badly because experience has taught me that the information will eventually be used against me. Truth be told, you are a spiteful person, not unlike me.
One constant, however, has been my depression.
I never made a show of my newfound opportunities. Then again, no congratulations ever came from you because of them. Nor, for the most part, from anyone else in the family. Many of the people who called themselves friends chose not to celebrate my successes either. It was apparently easier to mock them.
In Meet the Parents, Jack repeatedly reminds Greg that he is outside the Circle of Trust.
You did something similar.
Again and again, I was placed outside the circle.
The only times I began to recover were the times I stepped away. Distance, not closeness, allowed me to regain my footing. Yet each time I created that distance, I was persuaded to believe things would be different.
They never were.
I cannot carry the burden of your superiority, your narcissism, or the constant need to establish rank and status.
I believed we shared a deeper connection than that.
I was wrong.
Your loyalties were always to yourselves and to one another.
The invitation was friendship; the reality was membership by permission only.
I was never truly inside the circle.
Never an equal.
Never fully trusted.
Yet I trusted you.
And therein lies the entire difference between us. I was working toward a healthier family dynamic, a fact you unwittingly revealed when Gene announced, "The family has decided to help you." Even then, I was seeking connection while you were protecting a power structure. My misfortunes never disturbed the balance you preferred. What disturbed it was seeing me recover from them.
P.S. Contrary to what you said, our brother, who molested my daughter, was welcomed into your home while both you and I were there. He abused her between the ages of six and eight, while I was fighting to protect her from her callous and deranged mother and bearing the legal costs that effort required. It was all for nothing.
There is no excuse for what he did, and no forgiveness. Not from me, and not from Jennifer. She has never forgiven him. The quality of her life is evidence enough of the enduring harm he inflicted.
